Example of a Tree Case in New York State Trees that straddle.

Aug 02, My Tree Fell on My Neighbor's Car. If one of the healthy trees on your property falls on your neighbor's car during a storm, you are not responsible. Your neighbor may not be happy about it, but they must claim on their auto insurance. Most likely, the neighbor's insurance will file a subrogation claim with your insurer. Jan 18, Learn about who is responsible for covering damages caused by a neighbor's tree falling on your property, and learn the basics about suing your neighbor for the compensation you deserve.Jun 16, Even when a tree that technically belongs to your neighbor damages your home, you mulch new evergreen trees in winter still responsible for it.

This, of course, assumes the fallen tree was the result of something uncontrollable, such as a storm or fire. If you can prove the tree fell due to negligence, then your neighbor could be held responsible.

Jul 30, If a tree falls down into another’s person’s yard due to natural causes like a storm, the tree owner is not liable. The tree owner is responsible, if he’s been warned to take it down and he didn’t. If your neighbor’s trees are a threat to your property Estimated Reading Time: 3 mins. Sep 18, Usually, when a tree falls, it’s due to a violent storm or the simple fact that the tree was diseased.

Or, it was never maintained properly. It’s one thing to have the tree fall on your own property. When it falls on a neighbor’s property, however, the situation creates many questions about how Estimated Reading Time: 4 mins. Dear Monty: My neighbor’s tree fell on our property.

It destroyed our brick fence, and we have significant damage to the garage. My insurance agent gave me a very vague response about the insurance adjuster determining liability.

She said she would come out in the next few days. She also hinted that my policy might pay for the damage.